In a significant move to enhance the work-life balance of employees across Australia, the Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Closing Loopholes No. 2) Act 2024 introduces a new "right to disconnect." This part of the legislation, which received royal assent on 26 February 2024, aims to address the long-standing issue of blurred boundaries between work and personal life, exacerbated by the ability to be connected to work anywhere 27/4.
Rationale
The right to disconnect has been put forward as the antidote to the impact of the digital age on employees.
“For too long the boundaries between work and life have been blurred. Continuous connection to work has been normalised, and the pressure to be available at all hours has been building for working people across the country.”[1]
The expectation to always be available can have significant repercussions on employees' mental health, exacerbating work-related stress and contributing to mental health issues.
As lawyers, we see first hand both the benefits and detriments of constant connectivity. While technology facilitates flexibility, it also encroaches on personal time, making it challenging for professionals, including those with family responsibilities, to disengage from work.
Key Provisions and Practical Implications
From 26 August 2024, employees will have the right to reasonably refuse to respond to work-related communications outside their designated work hours, with this provision extended to small businesses from 26 August 2025.
The legislation stipulates several factors to determine the reasonableness of a refusal, including the nature and urgency of the contact, the employee’s role and responsibilities, and their personal circumstances.
Specifically, the Act allows employees to refuse to monitor, read, or respond to work-related contact outside of working hours unless the refusal is unreasonable. Similar provisions apply to third-party contacts related to the employee’s work.
Unreasonable refusal will be assessed on multiple factors, including the reason for the contact, the disruption caused, the employee’s compensation for being on call, and their personal circumstances.
This approach, in our view, provides a degree of flexibility in applying the right. While a high-level manager might be expected to respond to urgent after-hours emails, the same expectation may not apply to an entry-level administrative worker. Additionally, while calling an employee to cover an unexpected shift might be reasonable, frequent after-hours calls for non-urgent matters would likely be deemed unreasonable.
Importantly, the right to disconnect does not prohibit employers from contacting their employees outside regular hours. Instead, it protects employees if they reasonably refuse to engage in such communications when they are not expected to be working.
Fair Work Commission’s powers
Employees and employers have the option to seek resolution through the Fair Work Commission when disputes arise concerning the right to disconnect. The Commission has authority to issue orders that:
1. Prevent employees from unreasonably refusing to respond, especially if there is a risk that they will persist in doing so.
2. Prohibit employers from taking disciplinary action or compelling employees to remain connected in situations where it is reasonable for the employee to decline.
Anticipated Increase in General Protections Claims
Given that the right to disconnect is explicitly identified as a 'workplace right,' we anticipate an increase in general protections claims related to this new provision. Employees who face adverse actions for exercising this right are likely to seek redress through the Fair Work Commission, bolstering the significance of this legislative change.
Award clauses
A right to disconnect term is also to be inserted into all modern awards by 26 August 2024. The Fair Work Commission is currently consulting with interested parties about this term and will create guidelines as part of the process.
Employer Concerns and Compliance Strategies
Understandably, many employers are concerned about potential impacts on productivity and communication, particularly in fast-paced or client-facing industries. However, the legislation does provide exemptions for urgent matters, and a degree of flexibility to deal with different individual circumstances.
Employers may mitigate risks related to the right to disconnect by setting clear guidelines and expectations around after-hours communication. We often find that ensuring all parties are clear on what is expected can go far in preventing unnecessary disputes.
Generally, employers should now be thinking about what proactive steps to take to align with the new right to disconnect, including:
- Reviewing employment contracts and position descriptions to clarify expectations regarding after-hours availability.
- Updating policies and procedures related to after-hours contact.
- Training managers to understand the new rules and avoid adverse actions against employees who reasonably refuse after-hours contact.
- Develop workplace policies outlining the right to disconnect and provide training for all employees.
A Cultural Shift Towards Work-Life Balance
While the right to disconnect is expected to create some legal disputes, it may also prompt a broader cultural shift in workplace attitudes.
The right to disconnect represents a significant shift in Australian employment law, aligning with global trends to protect workers' work-life balance. While there will be a period of adjustment, there may be long-term benefits of this legislation for both employees and employers, including a healthier, more productive workforce, with a reduced turnover of staff and loss due to employee absences and ill health.
Employers should ensure they understand the changes and seek professional assistance as needed. Should you require further assistance please reach out to our employment team lawyers.
The information provided serves as a general guide and does not constitute legal advice. It is based on our research and experience at the time of publication. Please consult our knowledgeable legal team for any specific inquiries or advice relevant to your circumstances.
[1] Adam Bandt during the reading of the original Fair Work Amendment (Right to Disconnect) Bill 2023
