In today's challenging business landscape, companies face unprecedented conditions that may require a turnaround or transformation strategy. This article provides guidance for Chairs, Non-Executive Directors, and Executive Directors on the steps involved in transforming a business, being: identify the major causes of under-performance; define a path to recovery; organise a team to execute the turnaround; and beware of risks which could derail the plan.
Identifying the Major Causes of Under-Performance
To embark on a successful transformation journey, it is crucial to address the underlying causes of under-performance. These often include:
- Over-leverage and unsustainable debt.
- Drop in demand and/or increased competition.
- High fixed cost structure.
- Inadequate financial control.
- Poor execution of large projects or acquisitions.
- Sub-par board and/or management.
While acknowledging that not every distressed situation is a result of sub-par board and management, it is important to recognise the impact they can have. In many cases, newly appointed board or management teams inherit problems and are proactively working to address them.
Transformation Initiatives: A Path to Recovery
Transforming a distressed business requires a comprehensive set of initiatives that target various aspects of the organisation. Some key transformation strategies include:
1. Cash flow improvement.
2. Working capital optimization.
3. Attracting new capital.
4. Reduction of overhead costs.
5. Streamlining direct costs.
6. Operational transformation.
7. Cultural and governance change.
8. Revenue growth in existing products and markets.
9. Divestment of underperforming assets, businesses, or divisions.
10. Revenue growth through new products and markets.
The Importance of a Transformation Office in Turnaround Situations
There are five reasons why establishing a Transformation Office is imperative to facilitate a successful turnaround.
1. Significance of Change: Realistically expecting a different outcome requires significant changes, especially when sub-par board and management are major causes of distress.
2. Rebuilding Credibility: An external transformation office plays a crucial role in quickly rebuilding stakeholder credibility.
3. Expertise and Experience: A transformation office brings fresh perspectives, energy, resources, skills, financial acumen, strategic capability, and experience working with financiersand external stakeholders.
4. Objectivity and Communication: Independence and objectivity ensure rational decision-making and rapid implementation, while clear and concise communication facilitates organisational alignment.
5. Urgency: The sense of urgency embedded in a transformation office fosters timely actions.
The Transformation Office will ensure the following hygiene factors contribute to a successful transformation.
Matching Personalities: The transformation team must match the personality of the equity holders to establish effective collaboration.
Alignment: The transformation team comprising the board, management, and advisors should be in lockstep agreement, working cohesively towards the common goal.
Decision-Making and Implementation: A structured and coordinated approach facilitates decision-making followed by efficient implementation to minimise delays and bottlenecks.
Hands-on Approach: The transformation team should actively engage at the operational level, working closely with the staff to drive change.
The board and management should be aware of potential risks that can hinder success:
Weak Board or Management: A sub-par or under-resourced board and management team can undermine the chances of a successful turnaround. If key personnel were not replaced before the turnaround, they may need to be replaced during the turnaround to signal to external stakeholders that the board is managing the situation appropriately.
Lack of External Expertise: Neglecting the establishment of a transformation office led by external advisors or a dedicated Transformation Officer may limit the effectiveness of the turnaround efforts.
Superficial Improvements: Focusing solely on cash flow improvement without addressing the underlying strategic issues may result in temporary relief without sustainable progress. A successful turnaround or transformation usually requires one to two significant strategic changes.
Delayed Action: Failing to address the causes of distress promptly can impede the progress of the transformation.
Lack of Focus: Inadequate prioritisation of initiatives can dilute efforts and spread resources thin, impeding progress.
Adaptability: Knowing when to stick to the plan and when to adapt it based on changing circumstances is crucial to navigate the complexities of a turnaround.
Defining Success in Turnarounds
Success in turnarounds can be measured across different time horizons with each having different objectives.
Case Study: A Path to Recovery
In a recent case, our team was engaged to conduct a strategic diagnostic review for a distressed business experiencing significant losses. Collaborating with the board and executive team, we identified the key projects to facilitate the turnaround. While specifics remain confidential, the projects included:
1. Appointing a new Chairman to lead the board, which in turn led to the CEO being replaced.
2. Establishing a transformation officer to fast-track the implementation of strategic and turnaround projects.
3. Strategically pivoting around the core value proposition, refocusing on service as the primary offer.
4. Selecting and implementing core technology applications to support the revised business model.
5. Divesting one business and restructuring another to eliminate loss-making divisions.
6. Culturally transforming counter-productive behaviours to align with the adopted strategies.
As a result of addressing the underlying factors contributing to the losses, the business achieved breakeven performance within a year, and generated a significant profit a year later, and enterprise value increased three-fold.
Successfully navigating a distressed business towards recovery requires a holistic approach that addresses the root causes, establishes a transformation office, and ensures strong collaboration among the transformation team. By implementing strategic initiatives, swiftly addressing distress, and staying focused on the long-term vision, businesses can achieve sustainable transformation and enhance their enterprise value.
