Debate over trading

The National Association of Retail Grocers of Australia has challenged an independent study that found deregulating trading hours would not be detrimental to independent retailers.

NARGA chairman John Cummings also refuted comments made by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission chairman Graeme Samuel that independent supermarkets were not competitive with Woolworths and Coles on pricing.

Despite Mr Samuel's comments and the findings of the research, which was commissioned by the WA Retail Traders' Association, Mr Cummings didn't believe independent supermarkets were copping it from both sides. "We're not fighting the war on two fronts, it's the same front," he said. "Small business is in the same place it was 20 years ago, we're still fighting Coles and Woolworths."

The report examines the economic and social benefits of deregulated trading hours, finding reform will deliver greater competition, increased business investment and opportunities, and greater choice for consumers.

RTA director Wayne Spencer said the association commissioned the study in an attempt to dispel the myths plaguing the trading hours debate.

But Mr Cummings accused the RTA of looking after its own. "The RTA is looking after the people who pay their wages, and that's big business...I don't have a problem with that to a degree, but honesty will help the debate," he said.

Mr Spencer said deregulating trading hours would encourage stronger competition in WA and give both employers and employees more flexibility.

"What we're looking for is freedom of choice," he said. "We need to get rid of the fear and the myths that are out there."

Recently retired Fremantle Chamber of Commerce CEO John Longley said deregulation was not in the best interests of WA.

"We've fought [the CCIWA] over the issue and are delighted our efforts in that referendum were successful. Now it looks like all that effort is going to come to nothing because both political parties seem to be set on defying the wish of the people."